Taoiseach Leo Varadkar has denied breaching his “Constitutional duty” to inform the Dáil of government spending this year-despite knowing of overruns for the €1.4bn children's hospital.
Labour leader Brendan Howlin levelled the charge at the Fine Gael leader, also claiming he was incredibly "ignorant" when it came to the Budget process.
Mr Howlin said the Taoiseach and government knew about the excessive costs for the project when revised spending estimates for 2019 were presented to the Dáil in mid December. This was a number of days prior to Cabinet agreeing to the increased bill of €1.4bn for the hospital construction-an increase of €450m.
“Why was there no provision whatsoever for an additional capital spend which was known to be required for this project in the course of 2019 when this House was presented with the budget in October?” asked Mr Howlin.
The government accepts that it knew about the extra cost in November, including an extra €100m required from other departments. Health Minister Simon Harris apologised this week for not fully answering a Dáil question over the costs last September.
Mr Howlin told the house today that the revised estimates shared with the Dáil on December 19 were “inaccurate”. But Mr Varadkar rejected this, replying that the government did not know the full cost of the overrun and what changes would be made with capital spending until this week.
He added that while the revised estimates were done in December, a decision on reallocating funds was not made until January, after the Dáil commitment.
He also explained away the decision to fill the €100m funding gap for the children's hospital from other projects as a “virement”, where monies are transferred from one capital project to another and from one department to another.
Mr Varadkar also rejected comparisons of the children's hospital to previous overruns for projects such as the 'Bertie Bowl' and Dublin's Port Tunnel, adding:
We have got this right, by and large. The children's hospital is an exception but we will get it right too.
But Mr Howlin refused to accept this, suggesting Mr Varadkar was "ignorant" of the budgetary process. The Opposition leader insisted that if the Taoiseach knew late last year that the proposed spending for health in 2019 was not true, then “that was an inaccurate presentation in defiance of the Taoiseach's constitutional duty.”
