The government has been accused of running down the Defence Forces to such an alarming extent that, if there was a major security crisis, they have left the country “woefully unprepared, dramatically undefended, and shamefully exposed.”

That’s according to a retired Lieutenant Colonel who provided the keynote address at a protest in Cork organised by former members of the Defence Forces and the lobby group WPDF (Wives & Partners of the Defence Forces).

Retired Lieut Col Dan Harvey said the Defence Forces is “broken” and “in crisis” with “morale at an all-time low,” because they are “overlooked and undervalued, overworked, underpaid, over-stretched and undermanned.”

More than 1,000 attending the protest heard him say manpower levels in the Army, Naval Service and Air Corps were at an all-time low, pay was at an all-time low, – relative to other public servants – and it was therefore hardly surprising that retention was at an all-time low.


“The Chief of Staff (Vice Admiral Mark Mellett) is responsible for the military effectiveness of the Defence Forces. An impossible task when he’s constantly undermined by Department of Defence officials who hold decision powers over him,” Mr Harvey said.

“The Defence Forces and their families live in the real world, while this government lives in the half-world of pretence, perception and PR spin. The government needs to actually appreciate that respect and loyalty go two ways,” Mr Harvey said.

The Defence Forces defends democracy, this government defends itself. The Defence Forces protects peace, this government protects itself. The Defence Forces does respect and loyalty, this government does neglect and indifference.

He added that an umbrella group had been formed known as the Defence Forces Ireland Military Family Forum (DFIMFF).

'Morale at all-time-low' in 'broken' Defence Forces, Cork parade hears

Mr Harvey said for the first time in the nation’s history, “out of necessity, out of neglect, out of indifference, out of disrespect, out of lack of loyalty,” the DFIMFF finds it necessary to use democracy to defend itself.

He said that organisation had “identified and will target nationally our concentrated voting power and force where it will make the most impact, the planning is done, we have only to execute.”

Retired Brigadier General Ger Aherne, former General Officer in Command of 4th Brigade, was equally scathing of the government’s treatment of the Defence Forces. He pointed out that its minimal strength to deliver what it was supposed to was 9,500, which hadn’t been achieved for a number of years.

“The current strength is a dysfunctional 8,400. Pay and conditions for serving personnel is simply not defendable. Families are living in genuine poverty. Some 30% of serving personnel qualify to draw Social Welfare Family Income Supplement,” Mr Aherne said.

'Morale at all-time-low' in 'broken' Defence Forces, Cork parade hears

Other speakers, including Mervyn Ennis, chairman of the DFIMFF, and Shelly Cotter, a prominent member of the WDPF, who has a husband and son in the navy, said poor pay was leading to inexcusable poverty levels for some military families.

A number of wreaths were laid at the National Monument in Grand Parade.

Professor Cathal MacSwiney Brugha, grandson of both Terence MacSwiney, former Lord Mayor of Cork, and Cathal Brugha, former Minister for Defence laid one wreath on behalf of the 1916 Families Association.

Bill Egar laid one on behalf of the Army, Damien Eastwood on behalf of the Naval Service and Alan Byrne on behalf of the Air Corps.

Wreaths were laid on behalf of WPDF by Judith Butler Wharton and the Reserve Defence Forces by Lesley Doyle.

'Morale at all-time-low' in 'broken' Defence Forces, Cork parade hears

The Respect and Loyalty parade in Cork city yesterday. Photos: Larry Cummins.

Share it: